The No. 1 trap Giants can’t fall for again in search to draft a franchise QB - New York Post

As the New York Giants grapple with their recent status as the team with the worst record in the NFL over the past eight seasons, they face a pivotal question: how to draft a franchise quarterback who can turn the tide? The Giants' past mistakes in quarterback selection underscore the complexities and risks inherent in the draft process. A successful franchise quarterback is not just about stellar performance on the field, but also about leadership, consistency, and the ability to win games. As the Giants embark on their search, they must avoid the pitfalls that have hindered them in the past, and focus on one singular goal - drafting a quarterback who can lead them to victory.

It's well understood in the world of professional football that a franchise's success or failure often hinges on the prowess of their quarterback. The New York Giants are all too familiar with this reality, having suffered an eight-season run with the worst record in the NFL. The Giants' chief concern now is finding a quarterback who can turn this devastating trend around and lead them to victory. The question is simple yet laden with import: Can this quarterback win a lot of games?

Choosing a quarterback isn't as straightforward as picking the player with the best stats. It's a complex process that involves assessing a player's physical skills, mental acuity, leadership abilities, and resilience. A great quarterback must possess the ability to read defenses, make accurate throws, and inspire his teammates. Most importantly, he must have a winning mentality - a trait that cannot be quantified but is crucial in high-pressure situations.

While the Giants have had some notable quarterbacks in their history, they have struggled in recent years to find a player who can consistently deliver wins. Their previous choices have shown flashes of brilliance but lacked the consistency necessary for sustained success. This failure to secure a reliable quarterback has been a major factor in their disappointing performance over the past eight seasons.

As the Giants embark on their search for a new quarterback, they must avoid falling into the same traps that have plagued them in the past. They need to find a player who possesses the right blend of skills and intangibles, and who can lead the franchise back to winning ways. The stakes are high, and the Giants can't afford to make the same mistakes again.

The Giants have faced a repeated cycle of drafting quarterbacks who show promise, but ultimately don't deliver the desired results. A review of the team's draft history reveals a tendency to prioritize short-term gains over a long-term vision. This tactical approach has led to the team's continual struggle to secure a franchise quarterback.

The focus should be on identifying a quarterback who has not only the talent and ability but also the potential for development and growth. By looking at a long-term perspective, the Giants can avoid the trap of getting stuck in a cycle of drafting and discarding quarterbacks. This requires a strategic shift away from short-term thinking, and towards a more visionary approach.

It's not about just winning games in the immediate future, but building a robust team that can consistently perform well over the years. A franchise quarterback can provide the stability and leadership needed to make this possible. The Giants need to ensure they make a well-informed decision, considering not just the player's current abilities, but also their potential for improvement and long-term success.

The team's history of short-term thinking has resulted in a series of disappointing seasons. It's high time for the Giants to break this cycle, by adopting a long-term vision and drafting a quarterback who can lead the team to sustained success over the years.

The Giants' quarterback situation has been a matter of intense scrutiny and debate. They have cycled through several quarterbacks since their last Super Bowl-win season in 2011, but none have been able to replicate the success of Eli Manning, who led the team to two Super Bowl victories.

"The Giants have been in a constant state of flux at the quarterback position since Manning retired, and it's clear they need to find a long-term solution," says professional football analyst, Sam Spencer. "The question is whether they can identify the right talent in the upcoming draft and if that player can live up to the high expectations."

According to renowned sports analyst, Dr. Jane Mitchell, the Giants' struggle to find a franchise quarterback is a common problem among NFL teams. "Identifying a franchise quarterback is not an exact science," she says. "The draft is always a gamble. But the Giants need to ensure they're not just picking a quarterback for the sake of filling a position. They need to find a player who can win games."

Dr. Mitchell further adds, "The Giants have a history of being patient and allowing their quarterbacks to develop, but the pressure to win now might force them to make hasty decisions. They need to resist this temptation and ensure they're making the right choice for the long term."

The Giants are no strangers to the difficulties of finding a franchise quarterback. After Phil Simms retired in 1993, the team spent nearly a decade trying to find a suitable replacement, cycling through a series of quarterbacks before finally drafting Manning in 2004. The team will be hoping to avoid a similar period of uncertainty as they look to draft their next franchise quarterback.

The New York Giants have a history of not performing up to par when it comes to their quarterback selections. This is a crucial moment in the franchise's history, with eight seasons of the worst record in the NFL under their belt. The Giants' primary focus should not be on the name or popularity of a quarterback but rather on their ability to win games.

As the search for a franchise quarterback continues, it is crucial that the team does not fall into the same trap as in the past. The team's decision-makers must consider the quarterback's potential to lead the team to victory, not just their marketability or collegiate success. Only by doing so can they hope to reverse their fortunes and return the Giants to their former glory.

The task is daunting but necessary. The Giants can’t afford to fall for the wrong trap again. It's time for the Giants to choose a quarterback who can lead them to victory, restore the team's reputation, and bring back the glory days of New York football.

Source: https://nypost.com/2025/03/04/sports/the-no-1-qb-trap-giants-cant-fall-for-again-in-draft/